Book Reviews

Go To Hopkins & Company Homepage

Go to Executive Times Archives

 

Go to 2004 Book Shelf

 

Winfield: Living in the Shadow of the Woolworths by Monica Randall

 

Rating: (Read only if your interest is strong)

 

Click on title or picture to buy from amazon.com

 

 

Haunting

Readers have three books to choose from in Monica Randall’s offering, Winfield: Living in the Shadow of the Woolworths. One book introduces us to the great Long Island mansions, many of which have been demolished. Another book presents Randall’s personal story of attachment to those old mansions, especially Winfield, the former home of the Woolworths. The third book is a weird ghost story about Winfield. Any one of those stories would have made a good book. Instead, all three books alternate through the chapters of Winfield, and most readers will come away disappointed with the effort. Here’s an excerpt to test your tolerance for this book, from the beginning of Chapter 7, “The Gold Rose,” (pp. 103-107):

The movers were late. When they finally pulled up to the entrance, they were agitated and claimed to have passed the house by several times, thinking it was an institution of some kind. It wasn't the first time that had happened, and though I had mentioned to look for the stone arch beforehand, they were probably thinking of McDonald's twin arches rather than a thirty-foot replica of the Arc de Triomphe. It stood out, aberrant, on an avenue of mostly split levels and a Victorian cottage or two. Moments later I stood on the second-floor landing and watched as the two men carried the heavy rosewood furnishings up the stairs. As I directed each piece into its assigned room, I wondered if the ancient furnishings were happy to be home again in the rooms where they belonged. It was a silly thought, but I had always had a tendency to personify inanimate objects. "Welcome home," I said under my breath, and smiled gratefully as the men trudged by with their burdensome loads.

The Empress Josephine room at the top of the stairs was an exact replica of the original that Napoleon had designed for his beloved empress at their country estate, Malmaison, just outside of Paris. Despite its formality, it was cheerful and sunny, with French doors that opened out to a large terrace extending out over part of the driveway entrance. The room needed very little in the way of decorating, as it had been painted a warm beige color with upholstered inset panels of pale blue and peach flowers for the recent showcase exhibition. When I arrived that morning, there was a thick, powder blue rug rolled up on the floor in the downstairs hall with a card attached. "Hope this goes with your new room. Love, Andre." It was perfect.

When the movers finally left, I opened the glass doors of the terrace to let in some air. Everything outside was still engulfed in a gray vaporous mist, and you could no longer see the entrance gate, which was off to the left, or the Neptune fountain to the south. I stood there for a long time breathing in the salt air and fog, wanting to hold on to that moment for as long as I could. A seagull who had been perched unseen on the balustrade suddenly winged his way across the lawn and headed towards the beach.

I began to think about all the stories and rumors I'd heard during the girls'-school years and before that. It all seemed so long ago, and in that moment none of it mattered. Nothing was going to cloud my being there—not that day or any other. I continued to watch as the seagull flew and then vanished into the milky surreal whiteness that engulfed everything as if to cleanse and make everything new again. Sunny may have believed this was a sad and tragic place, but I was determined to make it a happy one. "Mind over matter," I said out loud, as if the bird now invisible could hear me. "Mind over matter," I repeated as the new phone in my room began to ring.

"How are you surviving moving day?" the voice at the other end asked breathlessly.

"Katia, you're my first call." I said, happy to hear an old friend's voice. "So how's it going?" she asked again.

"Well, I've got one room down and fifty-six to go," I said cheerfully.

"You're crazy, you know. I give you until dark before you freak out. You have to be a little nuts to stay in that place alone," she said, popping what sounded like bubblegum in her mouth.

"Katia, it's so beautiful here. I feel like I'm living in art, in esthetic overload. You must come for the weekend and see for yourself. I'll have another room pulled together for you by then."

"Do you hear anything odd?" she asked in her mischievous tone.

"Just an occasional frog croaking out by the pond," I answered.

"Well, you know I'm here if anything strange happens," she said.

"Nothing strange is going to happen. Thank you for calling." I said, eager to get back to work on the room.

"By the way, that's not the best phone number for you numerologically. It would be better to get a number with three fives in it. You should call and try to get it changed," she said insistently.

"Anything else?"

"Well, come to think of it, you should have waited until tomorrow before moving in," she said with her usual dramatic zeal.

"Too late now," I said.

"Not really. You could always spend the night in the car. But park outside the gate, at least until midnight," she shot back in an amused tone, not expecting me to take the suggestion seriously.

"Think about the weekend," I said, hanging up.

Katia and I had been friends for years. She was a numerologist, and one of the best astrologers in New York City. I had seen her on a television talk show and was impressed by what she had to say, so I called her for a reading, and we'd been friends ever since. Katia was also psychic and full of information on the subject of the paranormal, but the term numerology was new to me when I met her. Katia explained that it had to do with helping people pick the best dates and times to make important decisions in their lives. She said that all numbers vibrate on a certain frequency and that those vibrations could influence the success or failure of any given thing. Our addresses, license plates, and phone numbers, she claimed, all work together to play an important part in our lives. Katia was great fun to be with, but when she spoke of these things, she became very serious. Her earnestness was part of her charm.

The room felt damp and musty from nearly a year of not being used, but within a few hours everything was scrubbed clean, including the closets and a wall of glass shelves in the adjoining dressing room. I carefully unpacked a box of antique perfume bottles and arranged them on the now-gleaming shelves. I fussed over the placement of table lamps, silk scarves, and knickknacks, and put a pair of brass candelabras and a porcelain bust of a Victorian woman on top of the mantel. I found some daffodils growing wild in the surrounding woods and put them in a cut crystal vase to keep on the night table. When everything was finished, I took out the old photographs and was amazed at how quickly the room began to look the way it did in 1917.

After making up the bed, and covering it with an off-white, tufted satin bedspread, I sat back on it and studied the room, then noticed for the first time that the main door off the hall was missing. Back at the turn of the century, it was the custom for all the country houses facing the sound to have two sets of doors. One was used only during the summer months and was made of heavy oak, with open louvered slates to allow the ocean breezes to flow through. It was sturdy enough, but it hardly provided that sense of security one got from a real solid door, though I noted it did have a brass handle that could be locked from the inside only. The main doors had most likely all been removed during the showcase tours and were probably being stored somewhere in the building. I made a note to go on a search for the door in the morning. In the meantime I had no intention of sleeping that first night, so it hardly mattered if the doors were locked or not. I had waited so long for the opportunity to photograph Winfield at night, and I had brought along half a dozen rolls of infrared film to experiment with long time exposures.

Years before, at the Strand Bookstore in Greenwich Village, I had come across a curious book on how to photograph so-called haunted houses. The author of the book suggested using infrared film because it responds to heat rather than to light. It's a tricky thing at best as there is no ASA reading to work with and no way to control the results. Camera stores rarely stocked the film, so I had to special-order it. With high hopes I set the camera on a tripod at the top of the stairs and held the release button for ten- and twenty-second intervals.

I didn't really believe you could photograph ghosts, and the many pages in that questionable book that alleged that those were real ghosts caught on film in various castles and dungeons in far-off lands looked phony to me. But I was always drawn to the odd and unusual and was going to photograph the house anyway; if anything spooky turned up, all the better. I shifted the camera a few times, but the only light in the hall was from the ancient chandelier, which looked like an Oriental temple with bronze sentries standing guard all around the sides.

I worked my way down the hall in the east wing, climbing over unpacked boxes and furniture I'd yet to sort out, and I began taking shots of each of the rooms. I paused in front of the Marie Antoinette room, which had always been locked before. There was a deathly stillness about it that made me want to move on, and it felt twenty degrees colder than any of the other rooms. Delicate wisps of cobwebs obscured the tiny crystal pendants that hung from the chandelier, but I didn't turn it on. Instead, I waited for gray, haunted things to appear in the shadows, but there was nothing there. A cold, blue lunar light played on the brooding faces of the marble angels that supported the mantel. I took a shot of it in the dark, holding the exposure for a full two minutes. Then I found myself counting out four minutes. Secretly I felt I was playing with them, whatever they were. I was inviting them to dance with me, daring them to make themselves known through a camera lens. I was open to anything; it was only film. I thought about what they might look like, and childhood taunts played back in my head: Come out, come out, wherever you are. The silence made me leave that room and move back into the hall. From the staircase landing there was a spectacular view of the formal gardens below. The moon was shining like an auroral sun, illuminating the stone pavilion with its labyrinth of interlacing boughs of hanging foliage.

If you’re a fan of ghost stories, be sure to give Winfield a try. If you’re into historic preservation, and want to read more about the great old Long Island mansions, some of what’s in Winfield will interest you, but probably not enough, given the distractions of the ghost stories. If you enjoy reading personal stories, and can put up with some weird ghost stories and an obsession with the past, you might enjoy Winfield. If you’re a reader with none of those interests, take a pass on Winfield.

Steve Hopkins, January 22, 2004

 

ã 2004 Hopkins and Company, LLC

 

The recommendation rating for this book appeared in the February 2004 issue of Executive Times

URL for this review: http://www.hopkinsandcompany.com/Books/Winfield.htm

 

For Reprint Permission, Contact:

Hopkins & Company, LLC • 723 North Kenilworth AvenueOak Park, IL 60302
Phone: 708-466-4650 • Fax: 708-386-8687

E-mail: books@hopkinsandcompany.com

www.hopkinsandcompany.com