Book Reviews

Go To Hopkins & Company Homepage

Go to Executive Times Archives

 

Go to 2003 Book Review List

 

Disturbance of the Inner Ear by Joyce Hackett

 

Rating: (Mildly Recommended)

 

Click on title or picture to buy from amazon.com

 

 

Lingering Melody

Joyce Hackett’s novel, Disturbance of the Inner Ear, contains a most unusual central character, a cello, named the Savant. The narrator, Isabel Masurovsky, meets the Savant while on an outward and inward journey making connections and disconnections with people and places. Thanks to Hackett’s skill, the novel exudes Isabel’s grief like a fine cello. Her father, Yuri, was a survivor of Theresienstadt, who encouraged Isabel to develop her gifts as a cellist. Shortly after her Carnegie Hall debut, her parents die in an auto accident. Isabel abandons her art. We find her in Milan at the deathbed of the elderly Signor Perso, her cello teacher, lover, and guardian. More grief. Here’s an excerpt from pp. 64-5, after Isabel takes a job in Milan as the viola teacher for teenager, Clayton Pettyward:

In the dining room, Mr. Pettyward was standing behind his chair, reading, his thin rectangular glasses edging down towards the tip of his nose. There was no sign of Clayton. The long table was set with a white linen cloth and lit candles.

—Miss Masurovsky, he said, gesturing me to sit down. I stand until the women are seated. So try not to keep me waiting. I have fallen arches.

I nodded. The first dish cradled three small potatoes; the second, some withered, grayish green beans; the third, a pink gooey mash that Mr. Pettyward said was Gurney ham that a client had sent from Virginia. He served himself and passed the plate. It looked like the dog food Yuri and I had eaten once in Hungary, after he'd gotten a couple of bad addresses on someone he was looking for, and our money ran out. Still, I took a significant helping. My travels with Yuri had taught me to eat what there was.

Mr. Pettyward announced that he had had lunch at the Vatican with a cardinal. They had revisited the Bildersturm question. Mr. Pettyward was of the opinion that it was high time for Rome to finally demand rightful restitution from the Calvinists for the German Catholic church art destroyed in the riots after the Reformation. He took a potato, and shook his head, muttering to the effect that people never value what comes for free. Had he been offered half of what had been wasted on Clayton, he went on, he might have developed into quite a musician. For the moment he thought he would have to settle for enlightened connoisseurship. Had I managed to give our friend a workout?

I had decided to skate lightly over the conversation, my tone a light, lively vivace. Claytons got a math test tomorrow, I said, though the two of us had not yet spoken.

—He’s failing math, Mr. Pettyward said. In point of fact he has an extraordinarily high aptitude. He’s eligible for MENSA, but he’s too stubborn to join. I bought him a subscription to the newsletter, even had the executive director—he’s a close friend—cable him directly. Clayton prefers not to take the test. I have the newsletters bound, though. Sooner or later we all come to terms with who we are.

I sneezed.

—So have you managed to give our friend a workout?

I realized he'd meant the Savant. —This morning, yes.

—Bless you. And what did you play?

—The Franck Sonata.

Mr. Pettyward passed me the green beans. —How do you spell that? Oh. Of course. Frahnk. I didn’t recognize it the way you pronounced it. How many pages did you learn?

I shrugged stupidly. I knew the piece by heart, like everybody else.

—How many measures then?

I had no idea how to proceed, so I took another helping of meat.

Hackett’s knowledge and love of music, her sensitivity to emotions, and the inner life, and all the power of the concentration camps, come together in this tightly written, emotionally taut first novel. Be prepared when you pick up Disturbance of the Inner Ear: the cello can deliver lingering melodies.

Steve Hopkins, February 27, 2002

 

ã 2003 Hopkins and Company, LLC

 

The recommendation rating for this book appeared in the March 2003 issue of Executive Times

URL for this review: http://www.hopkinsandcompany.com/Books/Disturbance of the Inner Ear.htm

 

For Reprint Permission, Contact:

Hopkins & Company, LLC • 723 North Kenilworth Avenue • Oak Park, IL 60302
Phone: 708-466-4650 • Fax: 708-386-8687

E-mail: books@hopkinsandcompany.com

www.hopkinsandcompany.com