Book Reviews

Go To Hopkins & Company Homepage

Go to Executive Times Archives

 

Go to 2003 Book Review List

 

Blue Latitudes: Boldly Going Where Captain Cook Has Gone Before by Tony Horwitz

 

Rating: (Mildly Recommended)

 

Click on title or picture to buy from amazon.com

 

 

South Pacific Overtures

I couldn’t read more than a chapter a week of Tony Horwitz’ book Blue Latitudes: Boldly Going Where Captain Cook Has Gone Before. Maybe it was the concept: tracing the voyages of Captain Cook made me seasick. Maybe it was the decadent approach Horwitz took to following the hero. Had I had as much to drink while reading this, as Horwitz and cohorts seemed to have while reliving Cook’s journey, I might have provided a more mellow rating. (Or maybe my mellowness left the recommendation mild.)

Here’s an excerpt from Chapter 8, “Savage Island: The Search for Red Bananas”:

Sydney in winter was a joke by comparison, about as rugged as Los Angeles in January. The only thing that made it uncomfortable was that houses were drafty and uninsulated, designed for Australia’s long summers rather than the fleeting cool months. Still, reading Cook's account of his Antarctic probes was the literary equivalent of chewing on ice cubes. So it came as a relief when I turned to his writings about the Pacific islands he visited between his frigid southern sweeps.

I'd always wanted to see Easter Island, having marveled as a child at one of its astonishing stone figures in the Smithsonian Museum. But Cook was so sick during his brief stay at Easter Island that he barely went ashore, leaving it to his men to measure "those Colossean Statues" and to wonder how they'd been erected. Cook also made the island sound almost as bleak as the Antarctic seas he'd just departed. "No Nation will ever contend for the honour of the discovery of Easter Island as there is hardly an Island in this sea which affords less refreshments and conveniences."

Idly tracing the Resolution's path westward across the Pacific on an old chart, my finger brushed against a flyspeck labeled "Savage Island." I checked the index of Cook's journal. A brief entry from June 1774 explained the atoll's intriguing name. When the English attempted to land, islanders burst from dense woods "with the ferocity of wild Boars," Cook wrote, hurting rocks and spears. Cook and his men fired at their attackers, "stout well made men and naked except their Natural parts." A footnote said that the warriors' mouths were smeared red, as if with blood. "Seeing no good was to be got of these people," Cook wrote, he withdrew to the boats, gave the island its unflattering name, and sailed off.

I consulted my atlas. No mention of Savage Island. Nothing on my globe, either. Beaglehole, as so often, came to my rescue. He identified the island as present-day Nine. An almanac on my shelf described Niue as "the world's smallest self-governing state." A country I'd never heard of!

Then again, a lot of Pacific islets hadn't crossed my radar before I'd begun tracking Cook's voyages. I rang Roger on his cell phone. He was on a business trip, peddling books to librarians in Canberra, a much colder city than Sydney. "I'm driving through a bloody snowstorm," he said.

"Have you ever heard of Nine?"

"What?"

"Knee-ooo," I repeated, guessing at the pronunciation. "N-I-U-E."

"Is that a disease? In Africa? Or is it something I've got?"

"It's a country. Cook went there. He called it Savage Island. The natives had red teeth."

"Is it warm?" Roger asked.

"Must be. It's in the middle of the South Pacific."

"Let's go, then. Right now. I'm freezing here." The line crackled and dropped out.

The notion of just setting off appealed to me. Following in the Endeavour's wake had filled me with a certain wistfulness. I'd gone where Cook went, but I couldn't share his experience. The problem wasn't simply that I traveled by jet, rather than by wooden ship, to lands that had changed utterly since Cook's day. It was also that I carried an image of every place I went before I got there. This was the curse of modern travel: it was like reading a book after you've already seen the movie adaptation.

Niue seemed different. All I knew was its name and vague coordinates, plus the few paragraphs I'd scanned in Cook's journal. I decided to keep it that way. Traveling virtually blind to a land I hadn’t known existed, and whose name I couldn't even pronounce, seemed as close as I could get to the freshness of discovery I so envied in Cook's voyages.

Still. I had to set there. I called a travel agent. She hadn't heard of Niue, couldn't even find it in her computer. I rang Qantas, Air New Zealand, Polynesian Airlines. No Niue. But a saleswoman suggested I try Royal Tongan.                                                        

"You mean NEW-ay," a reservation agent said, correcting my pronunciation. Royal Tongan Airlines flew there once a week, from New Zealand. "But we don't fly back," she said.                          !

"You mean I'm there forever?"

"Not exactly. If you stay a week, there's a flight from Niue to Tonga. You can come back from there."

That was fine. I wanted to see Tonga, too. Cook spent several months touring Tonga's many islands and liked the place so much he named it the Friendly Archipelago. Still, a week in Niue sounded like a lot. Given the paucity of flights, there probably wasn't much to do on the island, perhaps not even a place to stay. I called Roger again to make sure he wanted to blow off his job for a few weeks to see both Tonga and Niue. He was staring out his hotel window at the swimming pool.

"It looks like an iceberg," he said, "or an 'ice island,' as Cook would call it. Count me in."

"What will we do in Niue for a week?"

"Drink."

"What if there's no booze?"

"We'll chew betel nuts. That's probably what turned their teeth red. Either that or they were cannibals." He laughed. "Maybe they still are. There's probably not much food. We'll be scratching around in the sand and drinking from coconuts." We made a pact to learn nothing more about Niue, and booked tickets on the next available flight.

 

IT WAS ODDLY relaxing to set off on a trip for which you couldn't prepare. What do you take to a desert island? Cook carried nails and beads; I packed lots of cash, in several different currencies. During our stopover at the Auckland airport, Roger added bottles of gin, rum, and chardonnay. "That's a fraction of what Cook carried," he said defensively. "He had barrels of Madeira, and we're not taking a drop of that." Then, at the departure gate, Roger spied a man toting aboard a case of lager. "Oh no, maybe they don't sell beer in Nine."

I was struck by something else: the size of our fellow passengers. Some were so big they could barely squeeze down the aisle of the small jet. The man seated next to me oozed over the armrest and almost into my lap before falling asleep.

Midway through the flight, a steward handed out customs forms for Niue. The list of prohibited goods included "handguns, flick knives, swordsticks, etc." Swordsticks? Also banned were "indecent goods," such as adult videotapes and magazines. Roger groaned. "You can be sure they'll be mad Christians, every crackpot cult." Making matters worse, our flight left early on a Monday morning and crossed the international dateline. "So we'll have to do Sunday all over again," Roger said. "Our Sunday and their Sunday. Not my favorite day and I get two on the trot."

There’s nothing I’ve read lately that’s quite like Blue Latitudes, and for that reason alone, it was worth reading. You may well feel the same.

Steve Hopkins, April 19, 2003

 

ã 2003 Hopkins and Company, LLC

 

The recommendation rating for this book appeared in the May 2003 issue of Executive Times

URL for this review: http://www.hopkinsandcompany.com/Books/Blue Latitudes.htm

 

For Reprint Permission, Contact:

Hopkins & Company, LLC • 723 North Kenilworth Avenue • Oak Park, IL 60302
Phone: 708-466-4650 • Fax: 708-386-8687

E-mail: books@hopkinsandcompany.com

www.hopkinsandcompany.com